Medical Necessity and Documentation Review

Medical necessity questions, in a Medicare audit, a denial, or a coverage review, require careful consideration of the patient’s condition, services provided, clinical documentation, and applicable coverage requirements. CuraLex evaluates the clinical information and supporting documentation to help identify potential gaps, inconsistencies, and questions that may require further review.

1

The rule

The NCD, LCD, or payer policy that applied on the date of service.

2

The record

What the documentation actually shows.

3

The review

Support, gaps, and questions that remain.

77%

of FY 2025 Medicaid improper payments were the result of insufficient documentation

CMS notes this is generally not indicative of fraud or abuse.

CMS, Fiscal Year 2025 Improper Payments Fact Sheet, January 2026. Documentation in this measure includes eligibility verification as well as clinical records. Not a measure of CuraLex results.

Clinical review is distinct from a formal coding opinion, a legal determination, or a payer coverage decision.

For attorneys handling audits, denials, and healthcare fraud matters, and for practices and organizations that want to know where they stand before an auditor asks.

The standard we review against

For many diagnostic and treatment services, Medicare coverage requires that the service be reasonable and necessary under Section 1862(a)(1)(A) of the Social Security Act, alongside other applicable coverage requirements. Preventive benefits and other services may have separate eligibility and payment requirements. CuraLex identifies the requirements applicable to the payer, service, and date of service before reviewing the documentation. Those requirements can include:

  • National Coverage Determinations (NCDs): CMS’s national decisions on whether a service is reasonable and necessary
  • Local Coverage Determinations (LCDs) and their billing and coding articles, issued by the Medicare Administrative Contractor for the region
  • CMS manuals, including the Program Integrity Manual that guides Medicare’s own medical reviewers
  • Medicare Learning Network (MLN) guidance, such as the Evaluation and Management Services booklet
  • AMA CPT code descriptors and guidelines and ICD-10-CM coding guidelines
  • Payer medical policies for Medicaid and commercial plans

When no applicable NCD or LCD addresses the service, the review considers other governing requirements and relevant clinical evidence, including safety, effectiveness, accepted practice, appropriate setting and personnel, and the patient’s documented needs.

For Medicare Advantage reviews, applicable Medicare coverage requirements and permissible plan criteria are considered. Medicaid and commercial reviews use the applicable program and payer requirements.

Why a nurse

Clinical review requires understanding the patient’s condition, the care documented, and how the record relates to applicable criteria. CuraLex provides registered nurse review of that documentation, with coding review by a certified coder and other specialized expertise included when the engagement requires it. CuraLex does not make payer coverage determinations.

For attorneys

  • Post-payment audits and overpayment disputes with Medicare contractors and Medicaid
  • Denial appeals, comparing the documentation to LCD and NCD criteria
  • False Claims Act and healthcare fraud matters: billed services compared with what the record supports
  • Provider defense and relator-side review
  • Claim samples, working alongside your statistician when sampling and extrapolation are involved

You receive a claim-by-claim review worksheet showing the service and code billed, the governing policy, whether each documentation requirement was met, the page that supports it, and a reviewer note, plus a summary of findings and a list of documentation gaps.

For physicians and healthcare organizations

  • Pre-audit review: an independent review of a sample of your claims for medical necessity and documentation
  • Documentation and coding accuracy review, with coding review by a certified coder
  • Provider and staff education: one-on-one and group sessions on documentation that supports medical necessity and the level billed
  • Ongoing monitoring through an Ongoing Consulting engagement

This work supports two of the seven elements in the HHS Office of Inspector General’s General Compliance Program Guidance: training and education, and risk assessment, auditing, and monitoring.

How a review works

  1. Scope: which payers, services, time period, and claims are in the review
  2. Policy crosswalk: the NCD, LCD, articles, and guidelines that applied on each date of service
  3. Record review: documentation compared with each requirement, cited to the page
  4. Findings: results in plain language, with education and corrective steps for providers, or work product for counsel

CuraLex reviews documentation against published coverage and coding criteria.

Request a Consultation